Quote from elektroakust.;64763
Agreed, but the worldwide spreading didn't really start before the 80s, right?
Wrong. It occurred in the '70s. When the DJing changed, and DJs went from playing 1 pass of an entire record to using two copies of a record and mostly playing and extending the breaks, the music created for dancing soon followed suit. Breaks and then tracks became longer and longer until many records were basically built around the break itself. This eventually inspired 12inch singles and remixes. All due to early Hip-Hop DJs rocking breaks.
Quote from elektroakust.;64763
Well, you never know... it's not impossible that they got wind of it during their first America tour in 1975.
But then again i doubt that. As in 1975 that could have only happened in very few special
places and only in the Bronx (?)
Nonsense. This style of DJing had already been going on for some time and had spread throughout the dance music world. If they went to a dance club while they were in the states, they heard it. Period. And likely could not help but be influenced by it. As for The Bronx, you have been brainwashed by the Boogie Down Bamboozlers who have been hustling this Bronx story for a living for eons. NOTHING happens in isolation in NYC. The Bronx is not in a vacuum. Most of these "pioneers" are my age or even younger, and like I said, I first heard Hip-Hop in the spring of '75 at the age of 15... IN CONEY ISLAND. That's about as far as you can get from The Bronx and still be in NYC. It was already old then. PappaWheelie Joe González, who has researched this extensively, points to Grandmaster Flowers (from Brooklyn) rocking breaks in Yankee Stadium (in The Bronx) in 1969! YEARS before Kool Herc's claim.
Quote from elektroakust.;64763
It could well be that, Flür as a professional drummer, having an ear for unusual breaks
parts in songs took inspiration from that before or at the same time as any Hiphop DJ started
extending Breaks with 2 turntables. As far as i remember he only mentions Funk and
James Brown as an extra source of inspiration for his drumming. His drumming in Kraftwerk
also slowly developed from rather experimental to that typical minimalized style of the later
Kraftwerk sound. So it didn't change "all of a sudden" really.
Did Kraftwerk do ANY dance records before TEE? Did they do a single track with at least a halfway danceable beat on it? I'm no big fan of theirs, but I sure can't think of one. So, they were a Krautrock and then experimental music group. Then, they tour the states in 1975. After that, they go back into the studio in 1976 and decide to make dance records, with funky beats underneath. But that ain't "all of a sudden"?
Quote from elektroakust.;64763
However. My initial point in this was and is that not all music that is loosely accepted
as "Electro" in our scene today relates back to the point when the electronic version of
Hiphop was labeled "Electro" (i.e. 1983). There is that second (if not initial) string that
goes back more direct to Kraftwerk and over the years developed into Electro substyles
you can find for example in 90s artists like Dopplereffekt, Drexciya, Deep Space Network,
Ectomorph, Anthony Rother (1997~2002) etc etc etc who all very much inspired our
contemporary generation of "Electro" producers. (Of course next to those that take their
inspiration rather from the 80s Hiphop-Electro side of things ...or even from both sides.)
Display More
I agree with you. After all, you people have labeled my music as "Electro" and it in no way related "back to the point when the electronic version of Hiphop was labeled "Electro" (i.e. 1983)". I wasn't paying any mind to what other cats were doing at the time, I was making original music using electronic instruments and drawing on a myriad of influences from the '70s... including Kraftwerk. If I could do that then then surely someone could do that (or a variation of that) now. However, THAT IS THE VERY ESSENCE OF HIP-HOP, borrowing from other influences to make break based music that rocks the crowd. My objection was not to you decrying the influence and significance today of '80s Electro Funk in modern Electro, it was saying that it had no relation to Hip-Hop. Again, it all comes down to how you define Hip-Hop, and my definition is much more broad and universal than the majority of The Bronx Carnival Barkers, most of whom never made a fukkin beat in their lives.
Quote from elektroakust.;64763
Which brings us to the next question... what exactly is "funky"? 
From my understanding in most contemporary productions the funky elements are really rare.
Just saying... i don't necessarily consider this a bad thing.
Kind of hard for me to define, but I sure as hell know it when I hear it. And you're right, it is very rare on the European side of things these days IMHO.